Jay's Brief

Google says there's no way to use Search without using artificial intelligence

A student sits at a classroom desk facing an open laptop with a completely blank screen, while a teacher stands nearby with one hand on a wall light switch beside a blank chalkboard and clock.
How much this touches your life Kids

Medium: if your child's school turns off Google's AI, students lose Google Search too, and parents may want to ask the school which way it is going.

What happened

On Tuesday, Google announced new AI tools and controls for schools. Its AI products, including Google Search, will be off for student accounts in kindergarten through 12th grade until school administrators turn them on. The catch: if a school blocks Google's AI, students lose Google Search. "Search and AI are deeply integrated," Google's Chris Phillips told the New York Times. Critics, including New York City's mayor, say Google is using its hold on search to force AI into schools.

What's actually going on

Google is putting four products behind one set of school controls: its AI chatbot Gemini, Gemini Notebook, Gemini in Classroom and Google Search. For students in kindergarten through 12th grade, all four start off until a school administrator turns them on. If a school leaves the AI off, Phillips told the Times, students won't have search and will see a message from their school saying it's not available.

Why tie search to AI? Phillips says the two are deeply integrated. The source doesn't say which parts of Search use AI. In general, search engines use AI to guess what you mean and decide which results come first, and many now use generative AI (the kind that writes new text when you ask) to write answers right on the results page. By Google's account, there's no Search without it.

Google's pitch for schools is Guided Learning, an AI study tool it says coaches students through problems instead of giving them the answer. Google plans to build it into Search.

Some critics see this as a penalty for saying no. New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani, who recently paused generative AI tools in city schools through eighth grade for a year, said Google is "trying to use its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools." Lina Khan, former head of the Federal Trade Commission, a US government agency, said much the same. The Guardian says Google didn't reply to its request for comment.

The word you'll hear

Bundling

When a company ties two products together, so you can't get the one you want without also taking the other.

In your life

If your kid uses a school Google account, their school now has a real choice to make. My guess: losing search is hard enough on homework that many schools will probably switch the AI on. That makes it worth knowing which way yours goes.

Be careful about

The choice on offer isn't really AI or no AI. On school accounts, it's AI plus search, or no Google Search at all. And the source doesn't say how well Guided Learning actually keeps kids from just getting the answer.

Where to get it

There's nothing for you to get. These switches belong to school administrators, and the source doesn't say when the change takes effect. One small step: ask your child's school whether it plans to turn on Google's AI for students, and what happens to search if it doesn't.

Go deeper

Google says there’s no way to use Search without using artificial intelligence
The Guardian, November 3, 2026